Reviewing instructional DVD's or books objectively is challenging because the skill level of the writer may be different than the skill level of the reader. With that in mind, I review these DVD's with my skill level in mind - as such, it will be a subjective review. However, I will compare the DVD sets with each other which would be somewhat of an objective review.
Further, I will go through several stages of review including:
1. Initial Impression upon watching
2. Drilling with a partner
3. Application in sparring
I will continously rethink my previous scores as I become more familiar with the techniques. This process will take time.
I will also assign a total score from 0-100% based on:
1. Effectiveness of the techniques
2. Presentation
3. Value
I will try to describe and review the techniques individually and categorize them as such:
1. Bread and Butter Technique
2. Situational but effective
3. Cool but Wishful Thinking
4. Inadequately described
5. Useless
The final review score should look like this:
100% - Perfect and a must have
90-99% - Excellent
80-89% - Very Good
70-79% - Good
60-69% - Ok
50-59% - Sub Standard
40-49% - Bad
30-39% - Horrible
0-30% - The Worst Jerry - the Worst...
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment